Commercial Invoice and Export Tax Rebate Documents Consistency Checklist: 30 Checks Before the Rebate Papers Are Filed

Read the commercial invoice against the export tax rebate documents before the rebate papers are filed: the invoice states what was sold, the rebate papers state what is claimed back, and the two have to name the same goods, the same quantities and the same value line by line.
How to use this checklist
This page covers the commercial invoice read against the export tax rebate documents only: the goods name and description read line by line, the quantities, the cartons and the weights read line by line, the shipping marks read line by line, and the invoice value read against the rebate filing basis. It does not repeat the commercial invoice checklist, the export tax rebate documents checklist or the commercial invoice and export declaration consistency checklist.
Work through the four stages in order, with the commercial invoice, the rebate papers and the export declaration open on the desk. Read every line on the invoice first, then the same line on the rebate papers, and mark the line only when the two read the same.
The exporter, the broker and the filing agent each read a different part of the pair, so rebate papers read on their own are not a record the filing can stand on. Keep the two papers together in one file, and hand the pair over whole.
Stage 1 — Goods name, description and classification read line by line
Stage 1 covers the goods name, the description and the classification read line by line: the name and the description on the invoice compared with the same lines on the rebate papers. A goods name that reads differently on the two papers is the gap found most often.
Read the goods name on the invoice first, then read the same name on the rebate papers. Where a description reads differently on the two papers, ask the broker in writing before the rebate papers are filed.
Stage 2 — Quantities, cartons and weights read line by line
Stage 2 covers the quantities, the cartons and the weights read line by line: the quantity, the carton count and the gross and net weight on the invoice compared with the same lines on the rebate papers. A quantity that reads differently on the two papers is the gap found most often.
Read the quantities on the invoice first, then read the same quantities on the rebate papers. Where a carton count reads differently on the two papers, ask the broker in writing before the rebate papers are filed.
Stage 3 — Shipping marks, origin and invoice value read line by line
Stage 3 covers the shipping marks, the origin and the invoice value read line by line: the marks and the origin on the invoice compared with the same lines on the rebate papers, and the invoice value read against the rebate filing basis. An invoice value that reads against a different basis on the rebate papers is the gap found most often.
Read the marks and the invoice value on the invoice first, then read the same lines on the rebate papers. Where a mark reads differently on the two papers, ask the shipper in writing before the rebate papers are filed.
Stage 4 — Invoice number, filing references and seller details read line by line
Stage 4 covers the invoice number, the filing references and the seller details read line by line: the number and the references on the invoice compared with the same lines on the rebate papers. An invoice number that reads differently on the two papers is the gap found most often.
Read the invoice number on the invoice first, then read the same number on the rebate papers. Where a filing reference reads differently on the two papers, ask the broker in writing before the rebate papers are filed.
Reading the invoice value, the quantities and the marks as one line from the commercial invoice to the rebate file
The commercial invoice and the rebate papers are read as one line from the invoice to the rebate file, and a break anywhere in the line breaks the whole read. The invoice states what was sold, the rebate papers state what is claimed back, and each line on the rebate papers answers a line on the invoice.
The invoice value is the line where the two papers most often part ways, because the rebate papers state no value of their own. The invoice carries an invoice value and the basis it was issued on, while the rebate papers carry the goods, the quantities and the marks, and read their value from the invoice. Where the invoice value was issued on one basis and the rebate papers were put together on another, the filing is held until the broker says in writing which basis stands.
The quantities and the marks are the second place where the line holds together, and they are the place the value line cannot reach. A quantity on the rebate papers that reads differently from the quantity on the invoice breaks the value line with it, because the value on the invoice was issued for the quantity the invoice states. A shipping mark that reads differently on the two papers breaks the line the other way: the cartons the rebate papers describe are no longer the cartons the invoice describes.
The pair is handed over whole, and the handover is the last place where the line is read before the rebate papers are filed. The invoice and the rebate papers carry the same invoice number, and the invoice value on the rebate papers reads against the invoice value on the invoice. Rebate papers read on their own say nothing about whether the filing can stand until the pair is read together.
Which invoice line to settle first when the rebate papers and the commercial invoice disagree
A line the rebate papers and the commercial invoice do not agree on is settled with the broker, and a goods name or a quantity that reads differently is settled with the exporter or the shipper.
| Difference found | When it applies | What to do first |
|---|---|---|
| Invoice value on the rebate papers reading against a different basis from the invoice | The two papers read the value on different bases | Ask the broker in writing which value basis stands |
| Quantity on the rebate papers reading differently from the invoice | The two papers name different quantities | Ask the exporter in writing which quantity stands |
| Goods name on the rebate papers reading differently from the invoice | The two papers name the goods differently | Ask the exporter in writing which goods name stands |
| Invoice number on the rebate papers reading differently from the invoice | The two papers name different invoice numbers | Ask the broker in writing which invoice number stands |
Why a rebate file is sent back when the invoice and the rebate papers disagree
Most rebate files sent back before the papers are filed come back to the same few causes. The invoice value on the rebate papers reads against a different basis from the invoice value on the invoice, so the filing has no agreed value to read the claim against. A quantity on the rebate papers reads differently from the quantity on the invoice, so the filing has no agreed quantity to read against.
The fix is the same in each case: read the invoice first, read the same line on the rebate papers, and ask the broker in writing which line stands.
A second cause is a goods name on the rebate papers that reads differently from the goods name on the invoice. A third is a shipping mark that reads differently on the two papers. A fourth is rebate papers with no invoice number, so the pair cannot be read against the invoice.
A fifth cause is a pair handed over with the invoice on one desk and the rebate papers on another, and no export declaration beside them. Keep the invoice, the rebate papers and the export declaration in one file, and hand the pair over whole.
What this invoice and rebate documents consistency checklist cannot settle for the exporter and the broker
This checklist cannot decide whether the goods qualify for a rebate the invoice does not support: the exporter and the broker decide that from the invoice and the written answers.
It also cannot replace broker or filing agent advice on a specific shipment. Where a shipment names a step this checklist does not cover, ask the broker or the filing agent in writing.
It also cannot say whether the goods match the description on the bill of lading: that rests with the bill of lading check.
Export documents guides on this site
- Commercial Invoice Checklist: 30 Checks Before the Invoice Is Issued
- Export Tax Rebate Documents Checklist: Declaration, Invoice, Bill & Receipt
- Commercial Invoice and Export Declaration Consistency Checklist: 30 Cross-Checks Before Filing
- Export Tax Rebate and Export Declaration Consistency Checklist: 30 Checks Before the Rebate Papers Are Filed
- Commercial Invoice and Packing List Consistency Checklist: 30 Cross-Checks Before Issue
- Commercial Invoice and Bill of Lading Consistency Checklist: 30 Cross-Checks Before Release
Related guides
- Commercial Invoice Checklist: 30 Checks Before the Invoice Is Issued
- Export Tax Rebate Documents Checklist: Declaration, Invoice, Bill & Receipt
- Commercial Invoice and Export Declaration Consistency Checklist: 30 Cross-Checks Before Filing
- Export Tax Rebate and Export Declaration Consistency Checklist: 30 Checks Before the Rebate Papers Are Filed
- Commercial Invoice and Packing List Consistency Checklist: 30 Cross-Checks Before Issue
- Commercial Invoice and Bill of Lading Consistency Checklist: 30 Cross-Checks Before Release
Official references
- US Customs and Border Protection: Trade
- ICC: Incoterms 2020
- FIATA: International Federation of Freight Forwarders Associations
- IATA: Cargo
For a route-specific logistics review, provide the product, origin, destination, packed dimensions, weight and ready date.
Request a shipment review ↗Frequently asked questions
What should be read first when the commercial invoice and the rebate papers arrive together?
Read the invoice first: the goods name and description, the quantities, the cartons and the weights, and the invoice value. Then read the same lines on the rebate papers, and mark each line only when the two read the same.
Why read the rebate papers against the commercial invoice instead of reading them on their own?
Rebate papers read on their own state no value of their own and say nothing about the sale they claim back. Read against the invoice, they show whether the goods, the quantities and the value claimed are the goods, the quantities and the value the invoice states.
How should the commercial invoice and the rebate papers be handed over?
Keep the invoice, the rebate papers and the export declaration in one file, with the invoice number on the invoice read against the invoice number on the rebate papers. Hand the pair over whole before the rebate papers are filed, so the broker reads the two papers together.