International Freight Insurance Claims Checklist: Notice, Evidence, Filing & Settlement

A cargo insurance claim is a file, not a phone call: notice, evidence, a written filing and a survey. This checklist follows a claim on a shipment from China, from damage or loss found at delivery to the settlement decision. Tick each item, and keep documents in one claim file.
How to use this checklist
This page covers the full claim, in order: notice to the carrier and the insurer, the evidence and the claim file, the written filing, and the survey and settlement decision. It does not repeat the notice-deadline article on this site, which covers only when and how to give early notice of damage; read that article first when damage is found. Use this page once notice has been given, to carry the claim through to a decision.
Work through the four stages in order, and do not dispose of, repair or repackage the goods until the survey is settled. A claim filed without evidence, or with the damaged goods already thrown away, leaves the insurer with nothing to inspect. Keep the policy, the transport documents, the photos and every message with the carrier and the insurer together as one file, so every line in the claim traces back to a document.
A claim is judged on the file, not on the story. The insurer and the carrier read the same file: what was shipped, what arrived, what the damage is, what it is worth, and who was told and when. Where the policy, the bill of lading and the delivery documents disagree on the time limit for notice, follow the shortest one. Where the loss is large or the cause is unclear, ask the insurer or the carrier what they need before the next step, and keep the answer in the file.
Stage 1 — Notice and first evidence
Stage 1 starts the moment damage, shortage or loss is seen. Notice goes to the carrier and to the insurer, in writing, while the goods are still as received. The first photos are taken before anything is moved, opened or repacked, because the condition of the goods at delivery is the evidence the surveyor will ask for first.
Note the delivery reservation on the delivery receipt or the carrier record at handover, and keep it. A clean receipt with no reservation makes a later claim harder to argue, so write what is seen — damage, shortage, wet cartons, broken seals — before signing. Tell the carrier and the insurer the same facts, and keep the messages and the claim reference numbers together from the first message.
Stage 2 — Evidence and documents
Stage 2 builds the claim file. Every document that proves what was shipped, what it was worth, what arrived and what was lost goes into one file, and every line in the claim traces back to a document. A missing invoice, packing list or survey photo is the most common reason a claim waits: the insurer cannot value a loss it cannot see.
Match the claim to the original shipment before writing it: model, quantity, batch, invoice number and the value on the commercial invoice. Where the goods were bought under trade terms that split risk between buyer and seller, note the trade term and who bore the risk at the point of loss. Keep originals and copies separate, and keep a second copy of the file elsewhere.
Stage 3 — Filing the claim
Stage 3 puts the claim in writing and files it. The filing states what happened, what was lost, what it is worth and what is asked for, and it attaches the file built in Stage 2. File within the time limit in the policy or the carrier terms: a late filing is a common reason a claim is refused.
Write the claim in plain language and number each attachment, so the insurer can follow the file without asking for the same document twice. State the facts only — what was shipped, what arrived, what the damage is, what it is worth — and leave the cause open where it is not known. Keep proof of filing: the sent message, the receipt and the claim number.
Stage 4 — Follow-up, survey and settlement decision
Stage 4 follows the claim to a decision. The insurer may appoint a surveyor to inspect the goods, ask for more documents, or ask for a statement of what happened. Answer each request in writing and keep the answer in the file: a claim that goes quiet is a claim that waits.
Do not settle, repair or dispose of the goods until the survey is complete and the insurer has said so in writing. When the settlement offer arrives, check it against the filed value and the policy: what is paid, what is deducted, and what the payment covers. Record the decision, the payment and the closing of the file together.
Which claim route fits this loss?
A loss can point at the carrier, at the insurer, or at both, and the right route follows who bore the risk and what the documents say. Confirm the route with the insurer or the carrier before filing: filing with the wrong party costs the time limit, and the time limit does not wait.
| Claim route | When it fits | What to check before filing |
|---|---|---|
| Carrier claim | Damage or loss that happened while the goods were in the carrier care, and the carrier terms cover it | Carrier notice given, delivery reservation noted, and the carrier claim form and time limit confirmed |
| Insurer claim | Loss covered by the cargo insurance policy, whatever the cause stated in the policy | Policy cover, insured value and the policy filing conditions confirmed with the insurer or broker |
| Both carrier and insurer | Loss that may be covered by the policy and also caused by the carrier, so each party is told | Both filings made separately, each with its own claim number, and each party told about the other filing |
| Neither route yet | Cause or cover is unclear, or the loss is still being counted and valued | Notice given to both parties first to protect the time limit, then the route confirmed once the facts are clear |
Common reasons claims get held or rejected
Most holds come back to the same few errors. Notice was given late, or only by phone, so there is no written record of when the carrier or the insurer was told. The delivery receipt was signed clean, so the carrier reads the damage as happening after delivery. The goods were repaired, repacked or thrown away before the survey, so there is nothing left to inspect. The value claimed does not match the invoice, so the insurer asks for the calculation again.
The fix is the same in each case: correct the file, not the story. Ask the insurer or the carrier what is missing, supply the document or the correction in writing, and wait for the answer before the goods move. Do not change the invoice or the claim value after filing without telling the insurer: a value changed without a matching document is a new mismatch, and it holds the claim longer.
What this checklist cannot decide
This checklist cannot set the value of the loss, the cover under the policy, or who is liable for the damage: those follow the policy, the sale contract, the trade term and the survey. It cannot predict whether the insurer will pay a claim, and it cannot clear goods that customs or the carrier has not released.
It also cannot replace the insurer, the broker or the carrier advice on a specific claim. Where the loss is large, the cause is disputed, or the claim has been refused, ask the insurer or the broker before the next step, and keep the answer in the file with the claim. It cannot decide whether goods should be repaired, resold or disposed of: that follows the survey, the cost of repair, and the agreement with the buyer.
Insurance and claims guides on this site
- Freight Damage Claim Notice: Why Importers Should Report Early
- Damaged Import Freight: How to Document Packaging and Cargo Condition
- International Shipping Documents Checklist: Export, Transport & Customs Clearance
- Incoterms 2020 Comparison Table: All 11 Rules at a Glance
Related guides
- Freight Damage Claim Notice: Why Importers Should Report Early
- Damaged Import Freight: How to Document Packaging and Cargo Condition
- International Shipping Documents Checklist: Export, Transport & Customs Clearance
- Import Carton Shortage: Evidence to Collect Before Filing a Freight Claim
- Incoterms 2020 Comparison Table: All 11 Rules at a Glance
Official references
- US Customs and Border Protection: Trade
- ICC: Incoterms 2020
- FIATA: International Federation of Freight Forwarders Associations
- IATA: Cargo
For a route-specific logistics review, provide the product, origin, destination, packed dimensions, weight and ready date.
Request a shipment review ↗Frequently asked questions
Who should I notify first — the carrier or the insurer?
Notify both, in writing, when damage or loss is found. The carrier needs notice because the loss may have happened in its care, and the insurer needs notice because the policy sets a time limit for it. Tell both parties the same facts — shipment, goods, what was found — and keep the messages, the replies and the claim reference numbers together in the claim file.
What documents does a cargo insurance claim usually need?
A claim needs the commercial invoice and packing list, the bill of lading or waybill, the insurance policy or certificate, dated photos of the cartons and the goods, and a count of damaged, missing and sound items. Where the sale contract or the trade term matters, the contract is needed too. Keep the full set as one file, numbered, so every line in the claim traces back to a document.
What happens after the claim is filed?
The insurer may appoint a surveyor to inspect the goods, ask for more documents, or ask for a statement of what happened. Answer each request in writing and keep the answer in the file. When the settlement offer arrives, check it against the filed value and the policy. The claim is closed when the settlement decision, the payment and the full file are all recorded together.