Freight Invoice and Commercial Invoice Consistency Checklist: 30 Cross-Checks Before the Goods Sail

Read the freight invoice against the commercial invoice line by line before the goods sail: the parties, the goods description, the goods value basis, the vessel and the voyage, the invoice number, the bill of lading number, the freight terms and the trade term, each line read in turn.
How to use this checklist
This page covers the reading of a freight invoice against the commercial invoice only: the parties, the quantities, the goods description, the goods value basis, the vessel and the voyage, the invoice number, the freight terms, the invoice basis and the bill of lading number in the booking file, each line read from the freight invoice to the commercial invoice. It does not repeat the freight invoice verification checklist or the commercial invoice checklist.
Work through the four stages in order, with the freight invoice and the commercial invoice open on the desk. Read every line on the freight invoice against the line that answers it in the commercial invoice.
Each party sees a different part of the shipment. Tell each party where one reads differently.
Stage 1 — Shipper, consignee and notify party read against the commercial invoice
Stage 1 covers the parties read against the commercial invoice.
Read them first.
Stage 2 — Piece count, weight, volume, goods description and goods value basis read against the commercial invoice
Stage 2 covers the quantities, the goods description and the goods value basis read against the commercial invoice.
Read them first.
Stage 3 — Invoice number, bill of lading number and sailing read against the commercial invoice
Stage 3 covers the invoice number, the bill of lading number and the sailing read against the commercial invoice.
Read it first.
Stage 4 — Freight terms, invoice basis and trade term read against the commercial invoice
Stage 4 covers the freight terms, the invoice basis and the trade term read against the commercial invoice.
Read them first.
Reading the invoice number, the goods value basis, the freight terms and the invoice basis as one line from the freight invoice to the commercial invoice
The freight invoice and the commercial invoice are read as one line: the freight invoice is the carrier answer at the close of the booking, and the commercial invoice is the seller answer for the same goods at sale.
The shipper, the consignee and the notify party are where the line first parts ways. The freight invoice names all three, and the commercial invoice names all three, with the seller named as the shipper and the buyer named as the consignee. Where a party reads differently, the notice goes to a party the other paper never named, and the goods wait for the party the papers agree on.
The piece count, the weight, the volume, the goods description and the marks are the next place the line parts ways. The freight invoice names them as the shipper worded them, and the commercial invoice names the same figures and the same goods. Where a figure reads differently, the papers no longer answer for the same shipment.
The goods value basis is the next place the line parts ways. The freight invoice states the goods value basis for the goods it names, and the commercial invoice states the goods value basis for the same goods, with the basis following the trade term it states. Where the basis reads differently, the two papers answer for the same goods on different bases, and the papers say nothing until the seller and the carrier confirm which basis stands.
The vessel and the voyage are the next place the line parts ways. The freight invoice names the vessel and the voyage offered at booking. The commercial invoice names no vessel line and no voyage line of its own: the vessel and the voyage are read from the freight invoice against the shipment the commercial invoice names, with the port of loading and the port of discharge read the same way. Where the vessel or the voyage reads differently, the sailing the freight invoice names is not the sailing the shipment answers for.
The invoice number is the next place the line parts ways. The freight invoice names an invoice number, and the commercial invoice names an invoice number of its own: the two numbers are different numbers for different papers, and the read is not that they match each other but that each is stated and each points at the same shipment, tied by the order reference the commercial invoice carries. The commercial invoice names no bill of lading number line of its own: the bill of lading number in the booking file is read against the invoice number on the freight invoice and the invoice number the commercial invoice carries, and the number has to point at the same shipment.
The freight terms and the invoice basis are the last place the line parts ways. The freight invoice names the freight terms and the invoice basis the carrier agreed. The commercial invoice names no freight terms line and no invoice basis line of its own: the terms and the basis are read against the trade term the commercial invoice states for the same shipment. The issue date and the order reference are read the same way: the issue date on the commercial invoice is read against the issue date on the freight invoice, and the order reference the commercial invoice carries ties the two papers to the same shipment.
The invoice number, the goods value basis, the freight terms, the invoice basis, the trade term, the vessel, the voyage and the bill of lading number in the booking file are read together, and every line above still has to agree.
Which line on the commercial invoice to settle first when the freight invoice names it differently
A party that reads differently is settled with the seller; a number that reads differently is settled with the carrier.
| Difference found | When it applies | What to do first |
|---|---|---|
| Party reading differently from the party in the commercial invoice | The freight invoice and the commercial invoice name different parties | Ask the seller and the forwarder in writing which party stands |
| Piece count, weight or volume reading differently from the commercial invoice | The freight invoice and the commercial invoice name different quantities | Ask the seller and the forwarder in writing which figure stands |
| Goods value basis reading differently from the goods value basis the commercial invoice states | The freight invoice and the commercial invoice state different bases for the same goods | Ask the seller and the carrier in writing which basis stands |
| Trade term on the commercial invoice reading differently from the freight terms on the freight invoice | The commercial invoice and the freight invoice state terms that do not agree | Ask the carrier in writing which terms stand |
Why a freight invoice and the commercial invoice are sent back for correction before the goods sail
Most freight invoices sent back for correction come back to a few causes. A party is named that the commercial invoice does not name, so the notice goes to a party they never named. A goods value basis is stated that the commercial invoice does not state, so the freight invoice answers for the goods on a basis the other paper never named.
The fix is the same in each case: name the line, name the paper that agrees it, and put the answer on the file. Ask in writing, and keep the answer with the two papers.
A second cause is a piece count or a weight the commercial invoice does not carry, a third is a sailing the commercial invoice does not support, and a fourth is a term the commercial invoice does not answer for.
A fifth cause is a freight invoice handed over with no commercial invoice beside it. Keep the two papers in one file.
What this freight invoice and commercial invoice comparison leaves open for the carrier and the seller
This checklist cannot decide whether a vessel named on the freight invoice will sail as named: the carrier and the forwarder decide that.
It also cannot replace carrier, forwarder or seller advice on a specific freight invoice or specific commercial invoice. Where either paper names a step this checklist does not cover, ask the carrier.
It also cannot say whether the cargo inside the cartons matches the freight invoice: that rests with the loading record.
Export documents guides on this site
- Sea Waybill and Freight Invoice Consistency Checklist: 30 Cross-Checks Before the Waybill Is Signed
- Air Waybill and Freight Invoice Consistency Checklist: 30 Cross-Checks Before the Goods Fly
- Shipping Advice and Freight Invoice Consistency Checklist: 30 Cross-Checks Before the Goods Arrive
- Freight Invoice and Bill of Lading Consistency Checklist: 30 Cross-Checks Before the Goods Sail
- Bill of Lading Checklist: Parties, Freight Terms, Clean Bill & Originals
- Ocean Freight Booking Checklist: FCL, LCL & Carrier Handover
Related guides
- Freight Invoice and Export Declaration Consistency Checklist: 30 Cross-Checks Before the Goods Sail
- Sea Waybill and Freight Invoice Consistency Checklist: 30 Cross-Checks Before the Waybill Is Signed
- Air Waybill and Freight Invoice Consistency Checklist: 30 Cross-Checks Before the Goods Fly
- Shipping Advice and Freight Invoice Consistency Checklist: 30 Cross-Checks Before the Goods Arrive
- Freight Invoice and Bill of Lading Consistency Checklist: 30 Cross-Checks Before the Goods Sail
- Bill of Lading Checklist: Parties, Freight Terms, Clean Bill & Originals
- Ocean Freight Booking Checklist: FCL, LCL & Carrier Handover
Official references
- US Customs and Border Protection: Trade
- ICC: Incoterms 2020
- FIATA: International Federation of Freight Forwarders Associations
- IATA: Cargo
For a route-specific logistics review, provide the product, origin, destination, packed dimensions, weight and ready date.
Request a shipment review ↗Frequently asked questions
What should be checked first when a freight invoice is read against the commercial invoice?
Read the parties against the commercial invoice first, then the quantities, the goods description and the marks, then the goods value basis, then the vessel, the voyage, the invoice number and the bill of lading number in the booking file, then the freight terms, the invoice basis and the trade term. Keep the freight invoice with the commercial invoice.
What should be done when the goods named on a freight invoice read differently from the goods description in the commercial invoice?
Ask the carrier in writing which goods description stands, and put the written answer on the file before the goods sail. The goods named on the freight invoice have to match the goods description in the commercial invoice: where the two papers name different goods, the freight invoice points at goods the commercial invoice does not answer for.
What happens when the freight terms on a freight invoice read differently from the trade term the commercial invoice states?
Ask the carrier in writing which terms stand, and put the written answer on the file before the goods sail. The commercial invoice names no invoice basis line of its own: where the terms read differently from the trade term the commercial invoice states, the papers say nothing until the carrier confirms them.