Sourcing Arrival Acceptance Exception Claim Exchange Follow-Up Guide: From the Evidence Pack to the Claim Closure

The acceptance finds an exception, and the claim starts where the acceptance leaves off. This guide walks through the claim: gather the exception evidence, put the claim to the supplier, read the supplier reply, follow the exchange, the reshipment or the refund, and close the claim record in order.
How to use this guide
This guide covers the exception claim only: gathering the exception evidence, putting the claim to the supplier, reading the supplier reply, following the exchange, the reshipment or the refund, and closing the claim record. It does not repeat the sourcing arrival acceptance follow-up guide, which walks through the arrival count, the outer packaging check, the acceptance record and the exception follow-up that the claim starts from, or the sourcing inspection sampling guide, which walks through the first carton draw and the inspection report the exception evidence is read beside, or the sourcing pre-shipment final inspection follow-up guide, which walks through the inspection request and the release decision or the rework decision that the claim is read beside, or the sourcing inspection pass release and shipment follow-up guide, which walks through the release confirmation and the shipment handover that the reshipment is read beside, or the sourcing inspection report filing and traceability follow-up guide, which walks through the report number and the report version, the photo evidence and the video evidence, and the finding trace the evidence pack rests on, or the sourcing inspection pass packaging and marks recheck follow-up guide, which walks through the packaging recheck, the marks recheck and the recheck record the outer packaging evidence is read beside.
Work through the five stages, and do not close the claim record before the exchange, the reshipment or the refund stands. A claim closed before the exchange, the reshipment or the refund stands may answer for cartons the order never names. The order, the inspection report, the acceptance record and the claim record are the records the buyer and the supplier read.
Each stage keeps a record: note the exception evidence, the claim, and the supplier reply and the exchange, the reshipment or the refund drawn from it. A stage with no record is a stage the claim cannot answer for.
Stage 1 — Gathering the exception evidence
Gather the exception evidence: read the exception against the acceptance record it stands on, read the exception against the order it answers for, and put the photo evidence and the video evidence in the evidence pack beside the acceptance record. Gather the three together, so both read the same exception evidence.
Where the exception reads with cartons the acceptance record never names, note the cartons beside the evidence pack, and hold the claim open until the evidence pack stands beside the acceptance record. Where the exception reads with the order, note the reading beside the evidence pack.
Stage 2 — Putting the claim to the supplier
Put the claim to the supplier in writing: name the exception the claim answers for, name the evidence pack the claim stands on, and name the claim line the claim asks for — the exchange, the reshipment or the refund. Put the three together, so both read the same claim.
Where the supplier asks for more evidence, add it to the evidence pack beside the claim record, and keep the claim open until the supplier reply is read. Where the claim line reads with no evidence pack beside it, note it beside the claim record, and hold the claim open until the evidence pack stands.
Stage 3 — Reading the supplier reply
Read the supplier reply: read the reply against the claim it answers for, read the reply against the order it stands on, and note what the reply settles beside the claim record. Read the three together, so both read the same supplier reply.
Where the supplier reply settles the claim line, note the settlement beside the claim record, and follow the exchange, the reshipment or the refund the reply names. Where the supplier reply holds the claim open with no claim line named, note the open line beside the claim record, and ask the supplier in writing to settle it before the claim is followed up.
Stage 4 — Following the exchange, the reshipment or the refund
Follow the exchange, the reshipment or the refund: read the exchange against the claim line it answers for, read the reshipment against the shipment handover it stands beside, and note the refund beside the claim record it closes. Follow the three together, so both read the same claim follow-up.
Where the exchange reads with cartons the claim line never names, note the cartons beside the claim record, and ask the supplier in writing to settle it before the exchange stands. Where the reshipment stands with no shipment handover beside it, note it beside the claim record, and keep the claim open until the reshipment stands.
Stage 5 — Closing the claim record
Close the claim record once the exchange, the reshipment or the refund stands: note the closure beside the claim it closes, note the exchange, the reshipment or the refund beside the order and the supplier, and tell the supplier in writing that the claim stands closed. A claim closed against the claim line reads as it stands.
Where the claim stands closed, note it beside the order, with the exception evidence and the supplier reply, and tell the supplier in writing. Where a claim line still stands open, ask for it in writing before the claim record is closed. Where the claim record carries cartons the inspection report never names, note it beside the evidence pack.
Reading the exception evidence, the claim, the exchange, the reshipment and the claim closure as one line from the exception to the claim record
An exception claim is different from an exception with no claim beside it: the claim travels with the exception the acceptance finds, and the cartons and the outer packaging are read through the claim they carry. The exception evidence names where the follow-up starts, the claim names what the exception asks for, the supplier reply names what the supplier settles, the exchange, the reshipment or the refund names what the claim line closes, and the claim closure names where the follow-up ends, and the five are read together, not one by one, with the supplier beside the buyer at each reading.
The exception evidence is set from the goods at arrival because evidence is not one record repeated: the evidence the cartons read in, the evidence the buyer confirms beside the acceptance record, and the last evidence the closed claim record answers for before the closure. The evidence names the order behind it.
The evidence pack is read against the acceptance record, not instead of it: the pack the exception names, the cartons the pack carries, and the order the pack reads beside the inspection report. A carton with no evidence reads as a reply, not as a check, and a reply does not answer the goods. The evidence pack is the pack the claim rests on, and the pack is read beside the acceptance record at each reading.
A single claimed carton with no claim record reads as a single carton; the same unrecorded carton at each reading reads as a pattern, and a pattern asks a different question: what stands behind the goods on the order. The reader notes the pattern on the claim record and names the cartons that carry it, so the buyer does not treat a pattern as single cartons.
The supplier reply is read beside the claim record, not instead of it: the reply as it stands, the record as it stands, and the cartons as they stand beside the reply. A reply read that names only the supplier note reads only the supplier note, and the goods go unread.
The claim record is the line beside the acceptance record: the record the claim names, the cartons the record answers for, and the supplier the record rests on. The record is read against the specification the order first confirmed, and the settlement stands on the supplier reply, in writing, before the closure.
The exception evidence, the claim, the exchange, the reshipment and the claim closure are read together. The claim ties each order to where the follow-up starts, the evidence ties the order to the goods each claim carries, the supplier reply ties the evidence to the cartons each order carries, the exchange ties the reply to the goods that stand, and the claim record ties the follow-up back to the claim set and closed. Where any link in that line is missing, it is settled with the supplier in writing before the closure. The record the closure leaves behind names the cartons, the evidence pack and the supplier reply together. All five read together.
Which exception claim difference to settle first when the claim and the supplier reply do not match
An exception claim difference is settled against the specification; the follow-up is closed when the supplier and the buyer read the same claim.
| Difference found | When it applies | What to do first |
|---|---|---|
| The exception evidence names cartons the acceptance record never names | The evidence pack and the acceptance record read differently | Read the evidence pack, the acceptance record and the order together |
| The supplier reply holds the claim open with no claim line named | The reply names no exchange, no reshipment and no refund | Ask the supplier in writing which claim line the reply answers for |
| The exchange reads with cartons the claim line never names | The exchange and the claim line read differently | Read the exchange, the claim line and the order together |
| The reshipment stands with no shipment handover beside it | The reshipment leaves the follow-up neither followed up nor closed | Ask the supplier in writing which shipment the reshipment answers for |
| A refund stands with no claim record beside it | The refund leaves the claim with no record to answer for | Follow the refund to its claim line beside the record |
Why an exception claim is held back before the claim record is closed
Most holds come back to a few causes. An evidence pack is set with no acceptance record named, so the pack reads with no record to answer for. A supplier reply is read with no claim line named, so it reads only the exception. An exchange is read only at the closure, so the goods go unread.
The fix is the same in each case: name the exception, name the evidence pack, and put the answer on the claim record before the claim is closed.
Next is a supplier that names no supplier reply for an exception the acceptance record names, then a claim that reads only the cartons at the front.
What this sourcing arrival acceptance exception claim exchange follow-up guide leaves open for the buyer and the supplier
This guide cannot decide whether a supplier will settle a claim line the reply holds open: the supplier decides, and the buyer confirms it in writing.
It also cannot replace buyer or supplier advice on a specific order. Where a supplier names a step this guide does not cover, ask the supplier.
It also cannot say whether the goods the claim never touched match the order.
Sourcing and consolidation guides on this site
- Sourcing Arrival Acceptance Follow-Up Guide: From the Arrival Count to the Acceptance Record
- Sourcing Inspection Sampling Guide: From the First Carton Draw to the Inspection Report
- Sourcing Pre-Shipment Final Inspection Follow-Up Guide: From the Inspection Request to the Shipment Handover
- Sourcing Inspection Pass Release and Shipment Follow-Up Guide: From the Release Confirmation to the Shipment Handover
- Sourcing Inspection Report Filing and Traceability Follow-Up Guide: From the Filed Report to the Traced Finding
- Sourcing Inspection Pass Packaging and Marks Recheck Follow-Up Guide: From the Passed Inspection to the Recheck Record
Related guides
- Sourcing Inventory Discrepancy and Cycle Count Follow-Up Guide: From the Discrepancy Classification to the Count Record
- Sourcing Arrival Inventory Check Follow-Up Guide: From the Inventory Count to the Inventory Record
- Sourcing Arrival Acceptance Follow-Up Guide: From the Arrival Count to the Acceptance Record
- Sourcing Inspection Sampling Guide: From the First Carton Draw to the Inspection Report
- Sourcing Pre-Shipment Final Inspection Follow-Up Guide: From the Inspection Request to the Shipment Handover
- Sourcing Inspection Pass Release and Shipment Follow-Up Guide: From the Release Confirmation to the Shipment Handover
- Sourcing Inspection Report Filing and Traceability Follow-Up Guide: From the Filed Report to the Traced Finding
- Sourcing Inspection Pass Packaging and Marks Recheck Follow-Up Guide: From the Passed Inspection to the Recheck Record
Official references
- US Customs and Border Protection: Trade
- ICC: Incoterms 2020
- FIATA: International Federation of Freight Forwarders Associations
- IATA: Cargo
For a route-specific logistics review, provide the product, origin, destination, packed dimensions, weight and ready date.
Request a shipment review ↗Frequently asked questions
What should be gathered first when the acceptance finds an exception?
Gather the exception evidence first: read the exception against the acceptance record and the order, note the photo evidence and the video evidence beside the claim record, and keep the claim open until the evidence pack stands, so the buyer and the supplier read the same exception claim.
How should the claim be put to the supplier?
Put the claim to the supplier in writing: name the exception, name the evidence pack, and name the claim line the claim asks for — the exchange, the reshipment or the refund — and ask the supplier in writing to settle it before the claim is followed up.
What should be done when the supplier reply holds the claim open?
Name the claim line the reply leaves open, read it against the exception evidence and the claim record, and ask the supplier in writing for it.